ED06S1: The Metric Tensor and the Laplace–Beltrami Operator
In ED02 and ED06, a curvilinear coordinate increment dqi was converted to a physical length using
a scale factor hi. We found, for example, that a small change in spherical azimuth dϕ corresponds
to a physical length r sin 𝜃 dϕ. Why is this true, and what replaces the scale-factor formulas when
coordinates are not mutually perpendicular?
The answer is the metric tensor. This article derives it directly from the ordinary Euclidean dot
product. We will then derive its inverse, the volume and area factors, and the general scalar
Laplacian, called the Laplace–Beltrami operator.
The route is
| position map | →coordinate tangents→metric gij, | |
|
| →length, angle, area, volume, | |
|
| →gradient and divergence→Δg. | | |
Every formula will be checked in familiar coordinates, including a nonorthogonal chart in which
off-diagonal metric coefficients cannot be ignored.
1 Preliminary distinction: geometry versus coordinates
We begin in ordinary three-dimensional Euclidean space. A point has a position vector r, and the
physical squared length of a small displacement is
This statement does not depend on whether the point is labeled by Cartesian, cylindrical,
spherical, or some unusual curvilinear coordinates. What changes is the expression for dr in terms
of the chosen coordinate differentials.
One should distinguish three things:
- the physical point and displacement in space;
- a numerical coordinate triple labeling that point;
- the basis vectors constructed from how the coordinates change in space.
The metric tensor records how coordinate increments combine into the physical length in
Equation (1).
2 Understanding upper and lower indices before deriving the metric
We use coordinates q1,q2,q3. The superscript here is an index label, not an exponent. In particular,
q2 names the second coordinate; it does not mean (q1)2.
Thus the position map is
We use indices i,j,k,… taking the values 1, 2, 3. A repeated index, once in an upper position and
once in a lower position, means summation over these three values. This is Einstein summation
convention.
For example,
where i is a dummy index. It can be renamed consistently without changing the sum:
By contrast, k is a free index in
There are three equations, one for each value of k:
| W1 | = g11V 1 + g
12V 2 + g
13V 3, | |
|
| W2 | = g21V 1 + g
22V 2 + g
23V 3, | |
|
| W3 | = g31V 1 + g
32V 2 + g
33V 3. | | |
The number of free indices must agree on both sides of an equation. A dummy index must be
summed exactly once; in conventional index notation it appears once up and once down. Repeated
letters must not accidentally be used for two different sums.
An ordinary partial derivative is abbreviated
Here ∂i carries a lower index because the partial derivatives of a scalar transform as components of
a covector. We will derive the relevant transformation law instead of simply asserting
it.
3 The coordinate basis comes from differentiating the position map
Apply the multivariable differential rule to Equation (2):
| dr | = dq1 + dq2 + dq3. | (7) |
Define three tangent vectors
They are called the coordinate basis or covariant basis vectors. They are not necessarily unit
vectors and are not necessarily perpendicular.
With this definition, Equation (7) becomes
Explicitly, this says dr = e1dq1 + e
2dq2 + e
3dq3.
If only coordinate q2 changes, the local displacement is
Thus e2 is the tangent to the curve obtained by varying q2 while keeping the other coordinates
fixed.
Figure 1. Local coordinate tangents arise by varying one coordinate at a time. Their lengths and
mutual angles, rather than just their names, determine the metric.
4 The metric tensor emerges from the squared length
Return to physical squared length:
Substitute Equation (9):
The scalar coordinate differentials can be taken outside the dot product:
The coefficients are so important that we name them:
We have thus derived the line-element relation
No advanced geometry was assumed. The metric coefficients are the dot products of the coordinate
tangent vectors.
What the indices actually say
For three coordinates, Equation (15) expands to
| ds2 = | g
11(dq1)2 + g
22(dq2)2 + g
33(dq3)2 | |
|
| + 2g12dq1dq2 + 2g
13dq1dq3 | |
|
| + 2g23dq2dq3. | (16) |
Why the factors of two? Because g12 = g21, and the full double sum contains both g12dq1dq2 and
g21dq2dq1.
The metric matrix is
It is symmetric because dot products commute:
For any nonzero coordinate increment, in a nonsingular Euclidean chart,
Thus the metric is positive definite wherever the coordinates are regular.
5 Lengths and angles are hidden inside the metric matrix
Set dq2 = dq3 = 0. Then
Therefore the physical distance along the first coordinate line is
This recovers the familiar scale factor
But the metric gives more information. The angle α12 between the first two coordinate tangent
vectors satisfies
Thus the diagonal terms measure squared tangent lengths, while the off-diagonal terms measure
the failure of coordinate directions to be orthogonal.
For orthogonal coordinates, gij = 0 when i≠j and
The ED02/ED06 formula
is therefore the orthogonal special case, not the definition of the metric.
6 Why the metric is a tensor: a coordinate-change proof
Consider two coordinate descriptions of the same region:
Apply the chain rule to the position vector:
| ea | =  | (27)
|
| =   | (28)
|
| = ei . | (29) |
The metric in the new chart is
| gab | = ea ⋅eb | (30)
|
| = ⋅ | (31)
|
| =  gij. | (32) |
This is exactly the transformation rule for a covariant rank-two tensor. It guarantees that the
squared physical length is unchanged by relabeling points:
In matrix notation, if Ji
a = ∂qi∕∂qa, then
The entries change, but the physical length does not. This is why we call gij a tensor, rather than
merely a table of coordinate-dependent coefficients.
7 Contravariant and covariant vector components
A physical vector V can be expanded in the coordinate basis:
The coefficients V i are its contravariant components. This is consistent with the differential
displacement dr = dqie
i, for which the components are dqi.
Define the covariant components by taking dot products:
Substitute Equation (35):
| V i | = (V je
j) ⋅ ei | (37)
|
| = (ei ⋅ ej)V j | (38)
|
| = gijV j. | (39) |
This is called lowering an index with the metric. It is simply the operation of converting vector
coefficients into dot products with the coordinate basis.
The inverse metric
Let [gij] be the matrix inverse of [g
ij]:
where the Kronecker delta δi
j equals one if i = j and zero otherwise.
Multiplying Equation (39) by gki gives
| gkiV
i | = gkig
ijV j | (41)
|
| = δk
jV j = V k. | (42) |
Thus
The inverse metric gij is not generally obtained by taking the reciprocal of each metric entry. One
must invert the full matrix. Element-by-element reciprocals work for the diagonal entries only in a
diagonal metric.
Reciprocal basis
Define the reciprocal vector basis by
Then
| ei ⋅ e
k | = gij(e
j ⋅ ek) | (45)
|
| = gijg
jk = δi
k. | (46) |
Consequently
with
The coordinate basis and the reciprocal basis need not be parallel in a nonorthogonal chart. This is
why upper and lower indices are useful rather than decorative.
Figure 2. In a skew coordinate chart, the two tangent basis vectors are not perpendicular, and the
reciprocal basis is different. The reciprocal vectors isolate the corresponding contravariant
components by dot product.
8 Why vector and covector components transform differently
The metric transformation law is useful, but the notation becomes much more intuitive if we also
derive the transformations of vector components and scalar derivatives.
Start with the same physical vector expressed in two coordinate bases:
Use the transformation of coordinate basis vectors,
Then
The basis vectors are linearly independent, so their coefficients agree:
Multiply by the Jacobian of the inverse coordinate transformation:
The coordinate basis vectors and their contravariant components transform oppositely so that the
physical vector remains unchanged.
Next consider a scalar f. The chain rule gives
These derivatives transform with the same Jacobian as the lower-index metric, not the
inverse Jacobian of Equation (53). They are the components of a covector or one-form
df.
The metric is exactly what converts between the two types of components:
These are not merely notation rules. Raising the index on ∂if is the operation that will turn the
scalar field’s derivatives into the physical gradient vector.
9 The metric as a Gram matrix
For a small physical displacement, write the columns of a 3 × 3 matrix as the three coordinate
tangent vectors:
Here each vector column is understood through its Cartesian components. Then
The matrix G is a Gram matrix: it contains every pairwise dot product of the basis vectors. Its
determinant measures the squared volume spanned by them.
Indeed,
| det G | = det(ETE) | (58)
|
| = det(ET) det E | (59)
|
| = (det E)2. | (60) |
Thus, for a nondegenerate chart,
This is the algebraic bridge between the metric and the familiar Jacobian determinant of
multivariable calculus.
10 Derivation of the volume element from the metric
A small coordinate cube has edge displacement vectors
Its unsigned physical volume is the magnitude of the scalar triple product:
Substitute the three edges:
| dV | = |e1 ⋅ (e2 × e3)||dq1dq2dq3| | (64)
|
| = | det E||dq1dq2dq3|. | (65) |
Use Equation (61):
For increasing, positively oriented coordinate intervals, we commonly write
Notice that g in this expression denotes the determinant of the metric matrix, not a gravitational
acceleration.
Figure 3. Three small coordinate changes generate a skew parallelepiped. Its volume is a scalar
triple product; the same number is obtained from the square root of the metric determinant.
Connection to ED06 scale factors
For orthogonal coordinates,
Then
so
This reproduces ED06. The determinant formula is its generalization to nonorthogonal coordinate
systems.
11 Derivation of a surface metric and its area element
A surface need not be defined by a constant coordinate in an existing three-dimensional chart. It
may be given independently by two parameters (u,v):
Its tangent vectors are
An infinitesimal displacement within the surface is
Take the squared length:
| ds2 | = (adu + bdv) ⋅ (adu + bdv) | (74)
|
| = (a ⋅ a)du2 + 2(a ⋅ b)dudv + (b ⋅ b)dv2. | (75) |
Define the induced surface metric
Thus
The physical infinitesimal parallelogram has edges adu and bdv, so
Use Lagrange’s identity
The right-hand side is precisely
Therefore
An oriented area vector also retains the surface Normal:
Equation (81) gives its magnitude. Equation (82) gives the corresponding orientation for an
ordered surface parameterization.
Figure 4. Two surface parameters generate tangent vectors a and b. The induced metric gives
their lengths and angle, while the cross product gives the oriented surface area.
Surface metric from an ambient coordinate metric
Suppose the surface is described in a three-dimensional curvilinear chart by qi = qi(ξ1,ξ2). The
physical tangent to the first surface coordinate is
The induced metric is its tangent-vector dot product:
Thus the surface metric is obtained by restricting the ambient metric to the directions tangent to
the surface. This construction works even if the surface is not a coordinate surface of the ambient
chart.
A subtle distinction
The full three-dimensional determinant det g controls three-dimensional volume; the induced
two-dimensional determinant det γ controls two-dimensional area. One should not insert
into a surface integral as if it were always the surface-area factor.
12 Example: Cartesian metric
The Cartesian position map is
Its coordinate tangents are
Consequently
The line and volume elements are the familiar
13 Example: cylindrical metric from the position map
Use (q1,q2,q3) = (s,ϕ,z) with
Differentiate one coordinate at a time:
| es | = cos ϕx + sin ϕy, | (91)
|
| eϕ | = −s sin ϕx + s cos ϕy, | (92)
|
| ez | = z. | (93) |
The dot products give
| gss | = es ⋅ es = 1, | |
|
| gϕϕ | = eϕ ⋅ eϕ = s2, | |
|
| gzz | = 1, | |
|
| gsϕ | = gsz = gϕz = 0. | | |
Therefore
The line element is
Its determinant and square root are
Thus
We recover all the ED02/ED06 scale factors from the metric without memorizing a separate
volume rule.
14 Example: spherical metric and the surface patch
Choose (q1,q2,q3) = (r,𝜃,ϕ) with 𝜃 measured down from +z:
| r = | r sin 𝜃 cos ϕx + r sin 𝜃 sin ϕy | |
|
| + r cos 𝜃 z. | (98) |
Differentiate with respect to r:
| er = | sin 𝜃 cos ϕx + sin 𝜃 sin ϕy | |
|
| + cos 𝜃 z. | (99) |
Differentiate with respect to 𝜃:
| e𝜃 = | r cos 𝜃 cos ϕx + r cos 𝜃 sin ϕy | |
|
| − r sin 𝜃 z. | (100) |
Differentiate with respect to ϕ:
| eϕ = | − r sin 𝜃 sin ϕx + r sin 𝜃 cos ϕy. | (101) |
The tangent magnitudes are
for r > 0 and 0 < 𝜃 < π. All off-diagonal dot products vanish.
Hence
The physical line element is
The determinant is
which gives
Induced metric of a sphere
Now hold r = R constant. The surface parameters are (𝜃,ϕ), so the surface metric is obtained from
∂𝜃r and ∂ϕr:
Its determinant is
Therefore
The origin of the sine is now explicit: a change dϕ at fixed polar angle runs along a parallel circle of
radius R sin 𝜃, so its physical length is R sin 𝜃 dϕ.
Figure 5. The sphere’s meridian and parallel directions have physical scale factors R and R sin𝜃.
Multiplying their differential lengths gives the induced-metric surface area.
15 An essential example: nonorthogonal coordinates
The real strength of the metric tensor becomes clear when the coordinate axes are skew.
Start with Cartesian (x,y,z) and define new coordinates (u,v,w) by
where k is a fixed dimensionless shear parameter.
The position vector is
Its coordinate tangents are
Take their dot products one by one:
| guu | = 1, | |
|
| guv | = k, | |
|
| gvv | = k2 + 1, | |
|
| guw | = gvw = 0, | |
|
| gww | = 1. | | |
The metric is
Its off-diagonal terms produce a cross term in the line element:
The determinant is
| g | = (1)(1 + k2) − k2 = 1. | (115) |
Hence
This is an instructive result. The coordinate cell is tilted, but this shear preserves volume.
Multiplying the three individual edge lengths would give the wrong volume because the edges are
not mutually perpendicular. The determinant takes their angles into account.
The inverse metric is
This example will also test the Laplace–Beltrami formula below.
16 From the metric to a gradient
Let f be a scalar field. Its ordinary total differential is
The physical gradient is defined by the condition
for every infinitesimal physical displacement.
Expand the unknown gradient in the coordinate basis:
Substitute dr = eidqi into Equation (119):
| df | = (Wje
j) ⋅ (eidqi) | (121)
|
| = gijWjdqi. | (122) |
Compare with Equation (118). Since the dqi are independent,
Multiply by the inverse metric:
Therefore
The coordinate components of the gradient vector are
This derivation explains why the inverse metric appears: the derivatives ∂if are covariant
components, and converting them to vector components requires raising an index.
For orthogonal coordinates, gii = 1∕h
i2 and e
i = hiei, giving
exactly as in ED03 and ED06.
17 Divergence from the physical volume measure
For a vector field V = V ie
i, divergence measures local outward flux per unit physical
volume.
In a general coordinate chart, the physical volume element is
Consider a small coordinate cell. On the faces q1 = constant, the oriented area vector per
coordinate area is
A useful algebraic identity for a right-handed regular chart is
where 𝜖ijk is the alternating symbol with 𝜖123 = 1.
The positive flux through the q1 face is consequently
| V ⋅ (e2 × e3)dq2dq3 | = V ie
i ⋅ (e2 × e3)dq2dq3 | (131)
|
| = V 1
dq2dq3. | (132) |
The fluxes through the two opposing q1 faces differ to first order by
Adding the analogous q2 and q3 pairs gives total outward flux
Divide by the physical volume
dq1
dq2dq3 and shrink the cell:
This is the metric divergence formula. It applies beyond orthogonal coordinates.
Figure 6. Divergence compares outward flux through opposite faces of a coordinate cell. The
physical face areas and cell volume both involve the metric determinant.
Why this does not require a separate formula for each coordinate system
The fields V i and the factor
both change with the chosen coordinate chart, but together
Equation (135) returns the same physical scalar divergence at the same point.
18 Derivation of the Laplace–Beltrami operator
The scalar Laplacian in Cartesian coordinates is
This geometric definition survives in arbitrary coordinates. The Laplace–Beltrami operator on
scalar fields is therefore
We have already derived both ingredients. First, the gradient has contravariant components
Second, divergence is
Replace V i by the gradient components:
| Δgf | = ∂i![[√g--(grad f)i]
g](https://images.physicslibrary.org/cache/objects/1589/make4ht/MetricTensorDifferentialGeometryAndTheLaplaceBeltramiOperator123x.png) | (140)
|
| = ∂i . | (141) |
This is the central generalization:
The determinant appears because divergence is flux per physical volume; the inverse metric appears
because the gradient converts derivatives of a scalar into a vector. Both factors now have physical
and mathematical explanations.
Unpacking both sums
The notation can be hard to read at first. At a fixed i, the inner sum in Equation (142)
is
The outer derivative then acts on that whole expression multiplied by
. Finally sum over
i = 1, 2, 3 and divide by
.
When off-diagonal gij are present, mixed derivatives generally appear. Those terms are necessary
in nonorthogonal coordinates.
19 Equivalent derivation using Christoffel symbols
The same scalar operator can be written using a covariant derivative ∇i.
For a scalar, the first covariant derivative equals the ordinary partial derivative:
However, the second derivative acts on a covector, so
Here the Levi-Civita Christoffel symbols are
This formula, too, can be derived rather than memorized. The Levi-Civita connection is
characterized by two properties: it is torsion free, so Γk
ij = Γk
ji, and it preserves the
metric:
Writing the last condition in components gives
Write two more copies with the indices cyclically permuted:
| ∂jgiℓ | = Γm
jigmℓ + Γm
jℓgim, | (149)
|
| ∂ℓgij | = Γm
ℓigmj + Γm
ℓjgim. | (150) |
Add the first two equations and subtract the third. Symmetry of the connection cancels the
remaining terms, leaving
Multiply by gkℓ and use gkℓg
mℓ = δk
m. The result is precisely Equation (146). Thus Christoffel
symbols represent the connection uniquely determined by requiring compatible measurements of
length and no torsion.
These coefficients account for how the coordinate basis changes from point to point. They are built
from the metric and its first derivatives.
The scalar Laplace–Beltrami operator is the metric trace of the covariant Hessian:
Proving equivalence of the two expressions
The determinant identity for a differentiable positive-definite matrix is
It follows from differentiating det G by the cofactor formula, or from Jacobi’s determinant rule
d(det G) = (det G) tr(G−1dG).
Consequently
Contract the Christoffel symbols:
| Γi
ik | = giℓ(∂
igkℓ + ∂kgiℓ − ∂ℓgik) | (155)
|
| = giℓ∂
kgiℓ | (156)
|
| = ∂k ln . | (157) |
In the second line, the first and third terms cancel after renaming dummy indices and using the
symmetry of giℓ and g
ik.
For a vector, the covariant divergence is
| ∇iV i | = ∂
iV i + Γi
ikV k | (158)
|
| = ∂iV i + (∂
i ln )V i
| (159)
|
| = ∂i( V i
). | (160) |
Thus covariant divergence equals the flux-derived divergence in Equation (135). Applying it to
V i = gij∂
jf proves that Equations (141) and (152) are equivalent.
The key point is that the determinant and inverse metric in Equation (142) already encode the
connection terms. One does not need to calculate Christoffel symbols separately to evaluate the
scalar Laplace–Beltrami operator.
20 How the Cartesian Laplacian is recovered
For Cartesian coordinates,
Thus
| Δgf | = ∂i(δij∂
jf) | (162)
|
| = ∂x2f + ∂
y2f + ∂
z2f. | (163) |
This reproduces the familiar Cartesian scalar Laplacian.
21 Deriving the cylindrical Laplacian from the metric
From Equation (94),
with
= s for s > 0.
Insert into the Laplace–Beltrami formula:
| Δgf = | ∂s(s∂sf) | (165)
|
| + ∂ϕ(ss−2∂
ϕf) + ∂z(s∂zf). | (166) |
Since s is independent of ϕ and z, this simplifies to
Check with a Cartesian scalar field
Let f = x2 + y2 = s2. In Cartesian coordinates,
In cylindrical coordinates,
| Δg(s2) | =    | (169)
|
| =   | (170)
|
| = 4. | (171) |
The same physical scalar result appears in both coordinate descriptions.
22 Deriving the spherical Laplacian from the metric
From Equation (103),
with
for r > 0 and 0 < 𝜃 < π.
Apply Equation (141) term by term:
| Δgf = | ∂r(r2 sin 𝜃 ∂
rf) | |
|
| + ∂𝜃(sin 𝜃 ∂𝜃f) | |
|
| + ∂ϕ . | (174) |
Move the factors independent of each differentiation outside the derivative:
| Δgf = | ∂r(r2∂
rf) | |
|
| + ∂𝜃(sin 𝜃∂𝜃f) | |
|
| + ∂ϕ2f. | (175) |
The r2 and sin 𝜃 factors are not arbitrary calculus decorations: they come from the volume element
and inverse metric of the spherical chart.
Check 1: the scalar r2
For f = r2,
| Δgf | = ∂r(r2 ⋅ 2r) | (176)
|
| = ∂r(2r3) | (177)
|
| = 6. | (178) |
This agrees with f = x2 + y2 + z2, for which Cartesian differentiation also gives 2 + 2 + 2 = 6.
Check 2: the Cartesian coordinate z = r cos 𝜃
Now choose f = r cos 𝜃, which is simply the Cartesian z coordinate. Its Laplacian should
vanish.
Radial contribution:
Polar contribution:
∂𝜃(sin 𝜃∂𝜃f) | = ∂𝜃(−r sin 2𝜃) | (180)
|
| = − . | (181) |
The azimuthal term vanishes. Hence
The apparently complicated radial and angular parts cancel exactly, as required by coordinate
invariance.
23 Laplace–Beltrami on a curved two-dimensional surface
The formula is not restricted to three-dimensional volumes. For a two-dimensional surface carrying
an induced metric γab,
For a sphere of fixed radius R,
Therefore
| ΔSR2f = | ∂𝜃(sin 𝜃∂𝜃f) | |
|
| + ∂ϕ2f. | (185) |
This operator differentiates along the surface. It is not the complete three-dimensional spherical
Laplacian, because radial differentiation is excluded when r = R is fixed.
A surface eigenfunction calculation
Take f(𝜃,ϕ) = cos 𝜃, independent of ϕ. Then
| ΔSR2 cos 𝜃 | = ∂𝜃(− sin 2𝜃) | (186)
|
| = − . | (187) |
Thus cos 𝜃 is an eigenfunction of the surface Laplacian with eigenvalue −2∕R2.
This is the simplest nonconstant example of the eigenfunctions that generalize to spherical
harmonics. In electromagnetic theory, spherical harmonics appear in multipole solutions of
Laplace’s equation and in wave separation.
24 Nonorthogonal test: Laplace–Beltrami for a shear metric
Return to the nonorthogonal coordinates in Equation (110). The inverse metric is given by
Equation (117), and
= 1.
All metric coefficients are constant, so Equation (141) becomes
Expand the terms:
| Δgf = | (1 + k2)∂
u2f − 2k∂
u∂vf | |
|
| + ∂v2f + ∂
w2f. | (189) |
The mixed derivative −2k∂u∂vf is essential. If we ignored the off-diagonal metric terms, we would
get the wrong operator.
Direct independent verification
Because x = u + kv and y = v, the inverse transformation is
By the chain rule,
Therefore
| ∂x2 + ∂
y2 + ∂
z2 = | ∂
u2 + (−k∂
u + ∂v)2 + ∂
w2 | (192)
|
| = | (1 + k2)∂
u2 − 2k∂
u∂v | (193)
|
| + ∂v2 + ∂
w2. | (194) |
This agrees exactly with the metric calculation in Equation (189).
25 Physical meaning: electrostatic energy and Poisson’s equation
In Euclidean space, the electrostatic field can be written
Gauss’s differential law is
Combining the two equations yields
This is Poisson’s equation written in general coordinates. The field equation is the same physics as
in Cartesian form, but its differential operator respects the metric.
The electrostatic energy density in vacuum is
The squared gradient is
Hence the total energy over a region Ω is
The inverse metric tells us how steep the field is physically, and the metric determinant tells us the
physical volume of the region over which that energy is integrated.
26 Integration by parts and the Laplace–Beltrami operator
The familiar Vector Identity
remains valid geometrically in a Riemannian setting when gradient, divergence, and dot product
are interpreted with the metric:
Integrate over a region Ω and apply the divergence theorem with the physical boundary
normal:
| ∫
ΩfΔghdV = | −∫
Ω⟨grad gf, grad gh⟩g dV | |
|
| + ∫
∂Ωf ∂nhdA. | (203) |
This is Green’s first identity in metric form, with ∂nh the outward unit-normal derivative.
For f = h and boundary conditions making the surface term vanish,
This explains why the Laplace–Beltrami operator, with the convention Δg = div grad, has
nonpositive eigenvalues under suitable boundary conditions. Some mathematical texts adopt the
opposite sign convention −Δg, so care is needed when comparing references.
27 Coordinate singularities and genuine geometric curvature
For spherical coordinates, g = r4 sin 2𝜃 vanishes at the polar axis and at r = 0. For cylindrical
coordinates, g = s2 vanishes on the axis.
These are failures of the particular coordinate chart: azimuth becomes undefined on an axis, and
spherical angles become undefined at the origin. They do not imply that ordinary Euclidean space
has become physically singular or curved there.
A metric tensor can also describe genuinely curved surfaces or spaces. For example, the induced
metric on the sphere has nonzero intrinsic curvature, even though the sphere sits inside ordinary
Euclidean three-space. By contrast, the full three-dimensional spherical-coordinate metric describes
flat Euclidean space away from its coordinate singularities.
The existence of nonzero Christoffel symbols does not by itself prove curvature. Even flat
Euclidean space has nonzero Christoffel symbols in polar or spherical coordinates. Curvature is
measured by combinations of Christoffel derivatives and products, assembled into the Riemann
curvature tensor, which is beyond the core derivation here.
28 What a metric does and does not determine
A metric determines lengths, angles, physical area and volume, the Levi-Civita connection, and the
scalar Laplace–Beltrami operator on a Riemannian manifold. Appropriate orientation information
is also needed to select oriented volume forms and outward normals.
The metric does not, by itself, determine charge density, electric potential, or a boundary-value
problem’s solution. One still needs the physical field equations, source distributions, boundary
data, and, for time-dependent problems, suitable initial data.
Nor does the spatial metric alone encode the full spacetime geometry of relativity. In special
relativity and general relativity one uses a four-dimensional Lorentzian metric of indefinite
signature; the same broad geometric philosophy survives, but signs, time, and causal structure
enter the theory.
29 A compact derivation map
The metric construction can be summarized through the following chain:
| ei | = ∂ir, | |
|
| gij | = ei ⋅ ej, | |
|
| ds2 | = g
ijdqidqj, | |
|
| dV | = dq1dq2dq3, | |
|
| (grad gf)i | = gij∂
jf, | |
|
| div gV | = ∂i( V i
), | |
|
| Δgf | = ∂i . | | |
For a two-dimensional surface, replace gij by the induced surface metric γab, and use its
determinant in both dA and Δγ.
30 Worked review exercise: recover a nonorthogonal metric
Let
Then
so
The infinitesimal area is therefore
However, a displacement with du = dv = δ has squared length
| ds2 | = (du)2 + 4dudv + 5(dv)2 | (209)
|
| = 10δ2. | (210) |
A naive Pythagorean sum using only the diagonal metric entries would give 6δ2 and
would be wrong. The off-diagonal coefficient measures the essential overlap of the skew
directions.
31 Further exercises
- Starting from r(s,ϕ,z), verify directly that gsϕ = 0 and gϕϕ = s2.
- Derive the volume element for spherical coordinates using both a scalar triple product
and
.
- Find the angle between the coordinate tangent vectors for the shear metric with k = 1.
- Verify explicitly that gikg
kj = δi
j for the shear metric.
- Parameterize a cylinder of fixed radius R by (ϕ,z) and derive its induced metric and
area element.
- Derive the metric of Plane polar coordinates from r(r,ϕ), then derive the
two-dimensional polar Laplacian.
- Use the surface Laplace–Beltrami operator to calculate ΔSR2(sin 𝜃 cos ϕ).
- Show using Equation (175) that Δg(1∕r) = 0 for r > 0, and explain why this does not
exclude a delta-function source at r = 0.
- Expand Equation (142) when the metric is a general symmetric 2 × 2 matrix whose
coefficients vary with position.
- Show that an infinitesimal oriented surface element depends on parameter order, while
the unsigned area in Equation (81) does not.
- Explain why the divergence formula contains
but the gradient formula contains gij
.
- Use Green’s first identity to explain why a harmonic function Δgf = 0 with zero
boundary values is identically zero on a connected bounded region under standard
regularity assumptions.
References
References
[1] D. J. Griffiths, Introduction to Electrodynamics, 5th ed., Cambridge University Press,
2023.
[2] H. M. Schey, Div, Grad, Curl, and All That, 4th ed., W. W. Norton, 2005.
[3] M. L. Boas, Mathematical Methods in the Physical Sciences, 3rd ed., Wiley, 2006.
[4] G. B. Arfken, H. J. Weber, and F. E. Harris, Mathematical Methods for Physicists,
7th ed., Academic Press, 2013.
[5] B. Schutz, Geometrical Methods of Mathematical Physics, Cambridge University
Press, 1980.
[6] M. P. do Carmo, Differential Geometry of Curves and Surfaces, Prentice Hall, 1976.
[7] J. M. Lee, Introduction to Riemannian Manifolds, 2nd ed., Springer, 2018.